fbpx
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Legal Notices
Lagniappe Mobile
  • News
    • Cover Story
    • Latest
    • Serial Stories
    • Bay Briefs
    • Community News
    • Open Documents
    • e-Edition
  • Baldwin
  • Commentary
    • Damn the Torpedoes
    • Hidden Agenda
    • Beltway Beat
    • The Real Deal
    • Weather Things
    • The Gadfly
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Cuisine
    • The Dish
    • Word of Mouth
    • Beer and Loathing
    • Cuisine Directory
  • Arts
    • Artifice
    • Art Gallery
    • The Reel World
    • Calendar
  • Music
    • Music Feature
    • Music Briefs
    • Music Listings
    • Submissions
  • Sports
    • The Score
    • The Starting Line-Up
    • From Behind The Mic
    • Upon Further Review
  • Style
    • Media Frenzy
    • Mobile Magnified
    • Horoscopes
    • Master Gardeners
    • Style Feature
  • Lagnia-POD

Select Page

Judge decides lawsuit cannot redraw congressional districts before 2020 elections

Posted by Gabriel Tynes | Apr 3, 2019 | Baldwin County, Bay Briefs | 0 |

State lawmakers are claiming victory in a federal court case seeking to redraw Alabama’s congressional districts. On March 27, U.S. District Court Judge Karon Owen Bowdre struck down many of the substantive complaints in the lawsuit, which was filed on behalf of eight African American voters around the state.

“I am pleased that U.S. District Judge Bowdre agreed with the Attorney General’s argument that the plaintiffs in the voting rights lawsuit against the state of Alabama’s congressional districting plan waited too long to file their legal challenge,” Attorney General Steve Marshall said in a statement. “Any attempt by the plaintiffs to alter Alabama’s congressional map, should they ultimately prevail in their lawsuit, would not occur until after the upcoming 2020 congressional elections. The bottom line is the upcoming 2020 congressional elections in Alabama will not be affected by the lawsuit as it progresses in court.”

As Lagniappe previously reported, the plaintiffs sued Secretary of State John Merrill last year over the claim the current congressional map, passed as SB 484 by the state Legislature in 2011, “packs” black voters into one district (District 7) and dilutes minority voting power in the others.

Plaintiffs were asking the court to agree the current map violates Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and to prevent the state from conducting more elections under that law, including the 2020 presidential and congressional primaries next March.

Merrill sought dismissal of the case in January, arguing the court had no jurisdiction and the case should be decided by a three-judge panel. That motion was denied. But this week Judge Bowdre sought to answer two remaining arguments: “First, Plaintiffs failed to demonstrate the existence of a proper remedy; and second, Plaintiffs’ claims are barred by the doctrine of laches.”

Bowdre found the complaint did in fact have legal standing, but also granted part of Merrill’s motion to dismiss based on the doctrine of laches. Essentially, the court determined that due to the 10-year cycle of the U.S. Census and resulting redistricting, the plaintiffs waited too long after the state’s 2011 redistricting plan was approved, thereby exposing the defendant to prejudice.

“The court finds that to force the state of Alabama to redistrict twice in two years — once based on nine-year-old census data — would result in prejudice. This prejudice was caused by plaintiffs’ inexcusable delay in waiting until 2018 to file suit. So, the doctrine of laches bars plaintiffs’ claim to the extent plaintiffs seek injunctive relief.”

The order preserved the plaintiff’s rights to declaratory relief, meaning they can still win the case on the merits of the arguments, but it would be decided without imposing any remedies.

This page is available to our subscribers. Join us right now to get the latest local news from local reporters for local readers.

The best deal is found by clicking here. Click here right now to find out more. Check it out.

Already a member of the Lagniappe family? Sign in by clicking here

Share:

Rate:

PreviousBill would require state lab to notify family when keeping an organ
NextCouncil to decide on neighborhood joining the city

About The Author

Gabriel Tynes

Gabriel Tynes

Gabriel Tynes joined Lagniappe in January 2012. A native of coastal Alabama, he has been recognized for excellence by press associations in Florida and Alabama, as well as the Society of Professional Journalists. He is a CMCJ/H.F. Guggenheim Journalism Fellow and the 2021 winner of the Association of Alternative Newsmedia's David Carr Award for investigative journalism.

Related Posts

Parents discuss ‘virtual school’ in Mobile County

Parents discuss ‘virtual school’ in Mobile County

September 9, 2020

Committee interviewing five candidates for MFRD chief

Committee interviewing five candidates for MFRD chief

May 3, 2017

Chinese compressor company to build plant in Loxley

Chinese compressor company to build plant in Loxley

July 25, 2018

Feds approve extended snapper season

Feds approve extended snapper season

June 14, 2017

Recommended Stories

God bless the (imperfect) US of A

By Ashley Trice

We’re not alone in this world

By Rob Holbert
By Andy MacDonald

Exploreum opens door to new reality

By Kevin Lee

As I lay dying

By Ashley Trice


  • Advertising
  • About Us
  • Contacts
  • Jobs
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Join the Sunday Brunch Newsletter

Search This Site

Browse the Archives

© Lagniappe Mobile 2022